Don’t Try to Boost Motivation — Just Ride the Wave

jeremy-bishop-286092Have you ever been forced to sit through a presentation by a “motivational speaker” — someone who’s been hired to squeeze more work out of you by whipping you into a frenzy of positive emotion?

If so, how long did your motivation last?

I’m betting that it was just long enough to look at your to-do list and see some things that you really really didn’t want to do. It was then that the frenzy faded and you sank back into your emotional status quo. Goodbye motivation.

Pete Seeger described this in song: “My get up and go has got up and went.”

This is where so many self-help “experts” try to sell us a bill of goods. They treat motivation as a problem to be solved. They work like mad to boost our motivation or help us ramp it up by ourselves.

But notice what happens when we internalize the gurus’ messages, do everything they say, and still feel unmotivated: We’re likely to see ourselves as failures.

Well, I have good news from Stanford University psychologist BJ Fogg: All the frenzy and shame are unnecessary.

Your lack of motivation is not a problem to be solved. Nor is it a character defect to eliminate.

In fact, you’re just normal. And starting from that premise gives you a much more effective way to solve the “problem” of motivation.

Motivation is a wave

The first thing to notice, says BJ, is that motivation is slippery. More precisely, it’s a wave. It rises and falls. It peaks and ebbs. This is something that any of us can verify by simple self-observation.

A second insight flows directly from the first: When motivation peaks, we temporarily feel like doing hard things. And when motivation ebbs, we gravitate toward easy things.

These are insights that we can apply to any behavior change.

Match behavior with motivation

Consider an example related to a key health habit — exercise. There are at least two ways to lay the ground work for this habit:

  • Do something easy, like simply pick out a pair of running shoes. At this point you don’t have to go for a walk. You don’t have to put the shoes on. You don’t even have to buy the shoes. You simply choose a pair that you intend to use in the future.
  • Do something hard, like find a list of personal trainers, call one up, and commit to a regular schedule of working with this person.

Which option makes more sense when your motivation is high? Of course: schedule the trainer. If you settle for simply choosing a pair of shoes, you squander an opportunity to accomplish something worthwhile and challenging.

And what will you do when motivation is low? If you want guilt-free success, then give yourself permission to just pick the shoes. If you instead try to schedule a trainer or go for a run, then you have to deal with the inner gremlin who says: Naaahhh. I just don’t wanna. And if you try to squelch that gremlin by artificially ramping up your motivation, your odds of success are low.

BJ sums up the big take-away: Don’t worry about motivation. Just choose the most desirable behavior that matches your current level of motivation — whatever that is.

In other words, ride the wave. When motivation peaks, do something hard while you still have the chance. And when motivation falls, go with the flow and do something easy. (For many more ideas about the latter, enroll in BJ Fogg’s free course on Tiny Habits.)

Harness high motivation in three key ways

High motivation is temporary. It can disappear in a matter of days, hours, or minutes. So, seize the precious opportunity that high motivation presents.

According to BJ, the most valuable things that you can do when highly motivated are:

  1. Structure your future behavior. Structured behaviors are presets — default options. For example: If you want to reduce your spending, then cut up your credit cards. If you want to stop eating junk food, then remove all that stuff from your kitchen and throw it away. If you want to exercise regularly, then schedule a personal trainer. This strategy is powerful because reversing your earlier commitment forces you to exert extra effort, such as calling the trainer to cancel.
  2. Reduce barriers to future behavior. For instance, go to the grocery store and buy a lot of vegetables. Then go home, wash them, cut them, and put all that good food into serving size containers. This reduces a barrier to making healthy meals when your motivation to cook sags and you feel the urge to do something easier — like going out to eat.
  3. Increase capacity. When your motivation to cook a healthy meal is high, for example, then take that opportunity to learn a new recipe. This is harder than going out to eat or chopping vegetables. But as you practice making the meal over the coming weeks, you’ll find this behavior easier to do — even when you don’t feel like cooking.

Note that I’ve numbered these options in the order that BJ recommends. So when motivation peaks, start with #1 before trying #2. And opt for #3 after experimenting with #2.

Don’t motivate change — facilitate it

These ideas might sound simple. If we really applied them, however, we’d create a quantum shift in our behavior.

Riding the motivation wave is especially crucial for people design programs for behavior change.

Is your job about helping people to exercise more, eat better, or adopt some other desirable habit? Then forget about boosting their motivation to do hard things, says BJ. Change your job title from motivator to facilitator. Start guiding people to surf their natural waves of motivation.

Note: This post came from my notes on a presentation by BJ Fogg about the motivation wave.

Do you want to write a book that will help people create positive new outcomes in their lives? I can help you produce a finished manuscript that’s grounded in principles of adult learning and behavior change.

For more information, email me at doug.toft@gmail.com

Photo by Jeremy Bishop on Unsplash